16 replies to this topic

[TND4NOS]

Welcome to the November 2008 Edited Screenshot Contest Only 4 shots this time guys so lets get voting. If your shot isnt here then most likely it didn't pass all rules.  

This months entries...

1)


2)


3)


4)



Regards,
Arron  

Edited by TND4NOS, 11 December 2008 - 11:12 AM.

[MIA-PILOT]

Voted for two its a very nice paint and nice pic.

[Mr. Schutte]

Would have been nice to receive a reason for my entry not being approved.

[Iron Eagle]

Mr. Schutte, on Nov 28 2008, 09:19 PM, said:

Would have been nice to receive a reason for my entry not being approved.

ya considering there was quite a big lap between when you said you sent yours, and when he put them up.

[pyruvate]

#1 is a nice unique edit, #2 is a screen shot.  #3 is also nice.

[Bogginho]

Naturelles, on Nov 29 2008, 08:49 PM, said:

#1 is a nice unique edit, #2 is a screen shot.  #3 is also nice.

And still, number two gets my vote.

[Iron Eagle]

Bogginho, on Nov 29 2008, 02:55 PM, said:

Naturelles, on Nov 29 2008, 08:49 PM, said:

#1 is a nice unique edit, #2 is a screen shot.  #3 is also nice.

And still, number two gets my vote.

I almost voted for 2, but didn't see any evidence of editing.

[Bogginho]

I doens't need to be edited. And it's the only screenshot that is 100% free from jaggies and/or blur. That plays a big role in how I vote.

But I must add that I also like the fouth edit. It's just a matter of taste that I chose the second one.

[Jigsaw]

Bogginho, on Nov 29 2008, 10:19 PM, said:

I doens't need to be edited. And it's the only screenshot that is 100% free from jaggies and/or blur. That plays a big role in how I vote.

I vote for aesthetic values, creativity and the amount of work that was put into an edited screenshot. Simply switching AA to 16x and hitting V with a too tightly framed subject isn't my idea of a great edit. Had I known that sharpness is more important than anything else to so many people then I wouldn't have put that much work into my vintage shot from September's contest and rather entered a sharp looking run-of-the-mill shot and been done with it in 5 minutes.

[Bogginho]

Jigsaw, on Nov 30 2008, 01:15 AM, said:

Bogginho, on Nov 29 2008, 10:19 PM, said:

I doens't need to be edited. And it's the only screenshot that is 100% free from jaggies and/or blur. That plays a big role in how I vote.

I vote for aesthetic values, creativity and the amount of work that was put into an edited screenshot. Simply switching AA to 16x and hitting V with a too tightly framed subject isn't my idea of a great edit. Had I known that sharpness is more important than anything else to so many people then I wouldn't have put that much work into my vintage shot from September's contest and rather entered a sharp looking run-of-the-mill shot and been done with it in 5 minutes.

I rather vote for a good shot, instead for a bad edit.

Edited by Bogginho, 30 November 2008 - 11:00 AM.

[Jigsaw]

Bogginho, on Nov 30 2008, 04:58 PM, said:

I rather vote for a good shot, instead for a bad edit.

Me too, when I see one. But sharpness alone doesn't make for a good shot. That's all I'm saying. And in this case I have the opinion that sharpness is all that the 2nd shot (which is leading the vote by far) has going for itself. The framing is too tight, as I said, the background is boring and the aircraft has been seen a thousand times.

[Bogginho]

We have different ways of seeing what a good edit is. You have yours and I have mine. Fine. Now let's bury the battle axes.

Edited by Bogginho, 01 December 2008 - 08:52 AM.

[Jigsaw]

Bogginho, on Dec 1 2008, 02:52 PM, said:

We have different ways of seeing what a good edit is. You have yours and I have mine. Fine. Now let's bury the battle axes.

I didn't even pick it up. I was merely discussing on a Discussion Board.

[Bogginho]

Jigsaw, on Dec 2 2008, 08:18 PM, said:

Bogginho, on Dec 1 2008, 02:52 PM, said:

We have different ways of seeing what a good edit is. You have yours and I have mine. Fine. Now let's bury the battle axes.

I didn't even pick it up. I was merely discussing on a Discussion Board.

No me either. The fact that no one of us is going to change our opinions (the three posts where almost the same) made me think that this was a worthless discussion. It would only continue for ever.

[Pierre.]

#4 looks the most realistic of all

[VFR_Pierre]

I like #2.

[TND4NOS]

Congratulations goes to Tako for taking out the November Edited Screenshot Contest. Awsome shots guys and see you next time  

Arron.