There are plenty of boat attractions that depart the island too. I would have liked to spend more time at some of the more scenic areas and beaches (especially Maho beach).
We didn't go to St. Barths but we did go to St. Thomas. Between Thomas and Maarten, go to Maarten. St. Thomas is didn't seem to have much of a local culture that you could experience. St. Maarten is still very touristy (obviously...they rely on it) but just going about the island you see some non-touristy areas.
Edited by LA_PHX, 26 September 2012 - 10:12 PM.