112 replies to this topic

[SXad]

for some reason... NUMBER 2 is my favourite...

its jus.... well.... really good!!

DEFINATLY my favourite...






AND P.S -- the fact that we don't know whos each screenshot it is, is a very good idea.... it is very fair that you don't vote for someone jus coz they took it, which i think that people have been duin these couple of months!!

Good work everyone!!! GREAT SHOTS!  

[djtom12]

Number 27 gets my vote - a superb shot! Well done and good luck to all the other competitors

[Hornet]

Julien, on Feb 2 2004, 10:26 AM, said:

Wow really tough choices  

I chose #4, simply amazing colors, aircraft, and clouds!!!    

I chose 4 because of that.

[Fox]

very nice shots everyone! May the best win! (and whoever does, share the prize eh? )

Edited by Fox666, 02 February 2004 - 03:13 PM.

[SAF_Chef]

Number 2 for me, tell you what though, since this comp started the quality really has just gone way beyond what i thought could be done, credit to all of you.

[Folgers]

WHY CAN'T I VOTE      sorry bout that, got a bit steamed.

Doug

[ruudpel]

if you would have read the voting rules, you would have known voting is only allowed for forum users who have more than 10 posts

[UltimatePilotAce]

I had a hard time voting, but i made my descision

[ManDango]

Not on vote, i guess maybe next month, plus people have already seen my screenshot that I entered. O well i still have hope , i noticed that some DO NOT follow the rules and are edited, that is not fair at all!

Bird

[ruudpel]

I have to admit I also think a few of them are edited

[Brad]

None appear edited to me - feel free to post which ones you feel are though.

[funtown34]

I'm not seeing any edits either. All look perfectly legal.

[ruudpel]

okay this probably will not help my popularity here..
but anyways
numbers 5 and 11 look edited
number 6 im not sure about that one..can't 'accuse' it of being an edit but i have a feeling it is

[funtown34]

Number 11 is the only one that looks anything like it would be edited. The fifth one is clearly natural though.

[Brad]

What is about those that makes you think they may be edited?

[funtown34]

I think he's just fooled by the add on scenery in #5. I take that back about #11 though. Looks totally unedited now that I really look at it.

[ruudpel]

5: the jet engine exhaust looks totally fake, all the pixels and stuff
11: i can't really describe it, the mesh on the background has a weird look, on overall the colors don't seem right
6: im not accusing this one since i'm not sure enough, but the lightning on the background seems a bit too much coincidence

[funtown34]

Yep you were fooled by #5's add on scenery.

[Brad]

What you see in #5 is the carrier deck - the blast platform (or whatever it's called) is raised to deflect the jetwash.

The colors in #11 seem to match an early dawn or late dusk flight.

And for #6, we've had very similar shots before but I'll let the author defend that one to account for the lightning coincidence.

[CombatAce]

none of them look edited
#6 seems to have been taken at Dusk/Dawn and the lightning caught perfectly, i don't know much about editing but you can see the lighther part around the lightning and it blends in into the cloud. So its my guess it was taken in FS and non-edited